One of the things I notice most in my work as a dog trainer isn’t actually dogs, it’s people, particularly how dog breed stereotypes influence the way people behave around certain dogs, often without them even realising it.
More specifically, how quickly people can change how they behave around a dog, often without even realising they’ve done it. People bring strong breed perceptions into these interactions, and those assumptions show up far more often than they realise, particularly with breeds that already come with strong reputations.
A Real Example of Breed Assumptions in Dogs
A really good example of this happened recently when a young Doberman puppy joined training. She’s a proper puppy, soft, a bit wiggly, curious about everything, sometimes unsure but generally very sweet.
When people first meet her, the response is lovely. Smiles, gentle voices, people crouching down to say hello. Quite often she gets mistaken for a Jack Russell or something similar.
Then someone asks what breed she is.
When the answer comes back, Doberman, you can almost feel the shift.
People step back. Hands come away. Body language changes. The warmth disappears. And the interesting thing is, nothing about the puppy herself has changed at all.
She hasn’t growled.
She hasn’t jumped up.
She hasn’t done anything differently.
The only thing that’s changed is the story in someone’s head.
When a Dog Stops Being a Dog and Becomes a Breed Label
That reaction isn’t really about the dog standing in front of them. It’s about everything that word “Doberman” carries with it.
Certain dog breeds come with a lot of baggage, and dog breed stereotypes play a huge role in how people react to them. People often label breeds such as Dobermans, German Shepherds, Rottweilers, and Malinois as aggressive, dangerous, or unpredictable, regardless of the individual dog’s behaviour.
This is something I see regularly when clients first get in touch for one-to-one dog training, especially when they’re already feeling anxious or defensive because of how others have reacted to their dog.
The same puppy who was being called sweet and friendly five seconds earlier suddenly feels “a bit scary”, purely because of the breed name attached to her.
Do Breed Traits Matter in Dog Behaviour? Yes, But They Aren’t the Whole Picture
Breed traits absolutely exist, and they matter. Understanding what a breed was developed for can help explain certain tendencies, energy levels, and training needs.
But breed should never be used as a shortcut to judgement.
Every dog is an individual. Genetics matter, but early experiences, socialisation, environment, training, handling, and the relationship a dog has with their humans matter just as much.
Breed gives us useful background information, but it never tells us who the dog actually is.
This is why I work so hard to tailor training to the dog in front of me, whether that’s through private behaviour support
or structured classes.
Two dogs of the same breed can be completely different in temperament and confidence.
A breed label can provide context. It cannot tell you who that dog is.
How Human Reactions Affect Dog Behaviour
Dogs are incredibly good at reading people. They notice when someone stiffens, pulls their hands away, avoids eye contact, or suddenly becomes tense. Even subtle changes in human behaviour don’t go unnoticed.
When they repeatedly experience people reacting with fear or caution, it can affect how they feel about the world. Over time, those reactions can create insecurity, anxiety, or defensive behaviour.
This is often something we address through confidence building and real-world training, helping dogs learn that people and environments are safe and predictable again.
In other words, the way people respond to certain dog breeds can help create the very behaviour they’re worried about.
Judging Dogs by Breed vs Meeting the Dog in Front of You
Dog breed stereotypes often say far more about human fear and misunderstanding than they do about the dogs themselves.
Next time you meet a dog, it’s worth pausing for a moment and asking yourself a simple question.
Am I responding to the dog in front of me, or to the story I’ve been told about their breed?
Looking at the individual gives you far more useful information than relying on reputation or stereotype. This approach underpins everything I do in my training, whether that’s with puppies in early foundations work
or adult dogs who need support learning to cope with the world around them.
Curiosity is more helpful than assumption, and fairness matters.
That Doberman puppy is still exactly the same puppy she was before her breed was mentioned. Whether she’s treated that way or not depends entirely on us.
Leave a Reply